How to merge WoW guilds without losing people
How to merge two WoW guilds: when it makes sense, the leaders' talk, ranks, Discord and the announcement, plus the pitfalls that lose members on the way.

In this post
- When does merging guilds make sense?
- Can guilds on different rulesets or factions merge in WoW Forever?
- How do you merge two WoW guilds, step by step?
- What should the merge announcement say?
- What are the common pitfalls when merging guilds?
- How do I check the merge is ready?
- How does GuildPro help with a merge?
To merge two WoW guilds, the leaders agree everything first (who leads, ranks, rules, raid nights, loot, one Discord), then announce it to both guilds on the same day and move people across in game. There is no merge button. In WoW Forever both guilds must already be on the same ruleset and faction.
When does merging guilds make sense?
When both guilds are too small for what they want to do, and they want to do the same thing. Two guilds of 12 who both want to raid Hyjal Summit at 20 players are a good match. A social levelling guild and a hard progress guild are not, however short both are.
Forever’s raid sizes make the maths plain. The first raids on 9 December are Barrow Deeps for 10, Hyjal Summit for 20 and Onyxia’s Lair for 40, per Wowhead’s raids overview. A guild that can fill a 10 but not a 20 has two choices: recruit, or merge. Our small guild growth guide covers the first.
Merge when:
- Both guilds raid, or want to, on the same nights and times.
- The culture matches: how you talk, how serious raid night is, how loot works.
- The leaders trust each other and can share the job.
Don’t merge when one guild is collapsing because of a conflict. You import the conflict.
Can guilds on different rulesets or factions merge in WoW Forever?
No. A Forever guild is one ruleset and one faction, so both guilds must already match. Blizzard’s wording is that characters can group, join guilds, run dungeons and raid only with players on the same ruleset and faction, per the starter guide on Wowhead.
The four launch rulesets are Normal, PvP, Roleplay and Roleplay-PvP. Forever has no realms, so there is no server transfer to think about, and Blizzard hasn’t announced a way to move a character to another ruleset or faction. If the other guild is Horde on PvP and you are Alliance on Normal, it isn’t a merge. It is one guild asking the other to start again. Our rulesets guide explains the four.
How do you merge two WoW guilds, step by step?
Leaders first, then officers, then everyone, all on one announced date. The order matters. If members hear about it from a rumour, you lose people before you start.
1. The leaders’ talk
Sit down (in voice, not text) and agree on the things members will ask about first:
| Question | Decide |
|---|---|
| Which guild do people move into? | Usually the larger one, or the one with the better name |
| Who is guild master? | One person. Write it down |
| Who are the officers, and what does each own? | Named jobs, not titles |
| Raid nights and times | One schedule |
| Loot rules | One system, and whether old standings carry over |
| Guild rules | One set, merged and short |
2. Ranks
Map each old rank to a new one before anyone moves. Officers from the smaller guild need real jobs, not an “Officer (merged)” rank with nothing to do. Members should land on the rank that matches their old one, so nobody arrives feeling demoted. Our officer roles guide has a split you can use.
3. One Discord
Discord has no merge feature, so pick one server. Before the announcement:
- Create roles for the incoming members and a welcome channel.
- Make sure raid, signup and officer channels are ready for the bigger roster.
- Plan to leave the old server up for a week or two with a pinned invite, then archive it.
4. The announcement
Both leaders post the same message, on the same day, in both Discords. Say why, what changes, what stays the same, and when the move happens. A template is below.
5. The move in game
Members of the joining guild leave their guild and are invited to the new one. Pick an evening when officers are online to send invites. The old guild master leaves last, once everyone is across.
6. The first joint event
Within the first week, run something that mixes the two groups: a dungeon night, a camp night, a raid. Don’t let the new roster split into “us” and “them” channels. Our guild event ideas has a list.
What should the merge announcement say?
Why it is happening, what changes, what doesn’t, and when. Both leaders post it on the same day. Copy this and fill in the brackets.
**[Guild A] and [Guild B] are joining up**
From [date], we are one guild: **[new guild name]**, on [ruleset], [faction].
**Why:** we both want to [raid Hyjal Summit / run 20-player raids / ...]
and together we can do it every week.
**What changes**
- Guild master: [name]. Officers: [name, job], [name, job], [name, job]
- Raid nights: [days, times, guild time]
- Loot: [system]. [Old standings carry over / everyone starts fresh on [date]]
- Discord: this is our server now. [Old server] closes on [date]
**What stays the same**
- Your rank: [old rank] becomes [new rank]
- [Anything else people care about]
**How to move:** on [date] at [time], leave [old guild] and whisper
[officer names] for an invite.
Questions? Ask any officer, or post in [channel].
What are the common pitfalls when merging guilds?
Most failed merges fail on people, not mechanics. Watch for these.
- Two guild masters. Shared leadership sounds fair and works badly. Pick one.
- Surprise. Members who learn about a merge from a rumour leave before it happens.
- Uneven loot. If one side’s loot standings carry over and the other’s don’t, the new raid starts with a grievance. A clean slate is simpler.
- Bench fights. A merged roster may suddenly have more raiders than seats. Agree how the bench works, and credit it, before the first raid.
- The “old guild” channel. A channel only one side uses keeps the split alive.
- Rushing. A merge done in a week, with no leaders’ talk, loses more people than it brings.
How do I check the merge is ready?
Go through this before you announce. Ticks save in this browser, and the button copies the list for your officer channel.
- Both guilds are on the same ruleset and faction
- Leaders agree on one guild master and named officer jobs
- Old ranks are mapped to new ones
- Raid nights, times and loot rules are agreed
- Guild rules are merged into one short set
- One Discord is chosen, with roles and channels ready
- The announcement is written and both leaders have read it
- A date and time is set for the move in game
- A first joint event is on the calendar
- The old Discord has a pinned invite and a closing date
How does GuildPro help with a merge?
It doesn’t merge guilds, but it makes the new roster quick to set up. Bring people into the guild you keep with an invite link, set their role, and let raid records start from there.
In GuildPro, an officer creates an invite link that joins people as raider, officer or admin, and each person ticks which characters they are bringing. A person can be in one GuildPro guild at a time, so members of the other guild leave it from their profile first. Raids they attended there stay recorded there. Admins set roles on Members & alts. All free. Set up your guild.
For the rest of what a Forever guild needs, see the WoW Forever guild checklist.
FAQ
Can you merge two guilds in WoW?
Not with a button. Members of one guild leave and join the other in game. The real merge is the agreement between the leaders: ranks, rules, raid times and one Discord.
Can guilds on different rulesets merge in WoW Forever?
No. In Forever a guild is one ruleset and one faction. Players on different rulesets or factions can't group or share a guild, so both guilds must already be on the same ruleset and faction.
Who should be guild master after a merge?
Decide before you announce anything. Often the larger guild keeps its guild master and the other leader becomes an officer with a named job, such as raid leader. Write it down.
How do I merge two Discord servers?
Discord has no merge feature. Pick one server, set up roles and channels for the new members, and post an invite in the old server before you archive it.
What happens to attendance and loot history after a merge?
Decide whether old records count. Many guilds start a clean slate for loot and attendance on the merge date, so nobody feels the other side brought an advantage.